Legal Matters

Public safety, not political control, must be the priority for policing

“Strong policing requires clear authority, but legitimate authority requires robust accountability.”

Photo by Patrick Bevan

Public safety is one of the first responsibilities of government, but public safety and political control are not the same thing. Ontario’s Bill 119 risks blurring that line by giving the Solicitor General the power to impose priorities on local police service boards and require those priorities to be written into their strategic plans.

The government’s argument is not frivolous. Guns, organized crime, illegal drugs, human trafficking and hate motivated violence do not respect municipal boundaries. The province has both the right and the responsibility to establish laws, coordinate enforcement and ensure that serious threats are not ignored simply because local leadership finds them politically inconvenient.

However, Bill 119 goes much further than establishing a common standard. Schedule 3 says the minister may issue a directive to a police service board, either generally or in a particular case, and the board must reflect that directive in its strategic plan. The minister may also set the deadline by which the plan must be reviewed and revised. These directives would not be treated as regulations under Ontario’s Legislation Act, meaning they would not automatically pass through the usual process governing regulations.

The most troubling provision is even clearer. Under existing law, police boards preparing or revising strategic plans must consult the police chief, municipal councils, First Nations, community organizations, businesses, members of the public and groups representing diverse communities. The plan must explain what concerns were raised and how they were addressed. Bill 119 specifically says those requirements would not apply when a board revises its plan to comply with a ministerial directive.

That is not a minor administrative adjustment. It turns a public planning process into a top-down instruction and that is always dangerous in the long-term.

The government correctly notes that the minister would not be permitted to order an arrest, direct an investigation or tell officers how to conduct a particular operation. Operational independence would formally remain. Yet strategic plans determine objectives, priorities, performance measures, and resource planning. Anyone who controls those priorities can influence where attention, personnel and money are directed, even without issuing an order to a single officer.

It also creates a basic accountability problem for taxpayers. Toronto residents fund the police service through the municipal budget, while the police board develops the plan and City Council determines how much taxpayers will provide. If Queen’s Park can compel a change in priorities that requires more officers, technology or specialized units, residents deserve to know who made the decision, what it will cost and who will answer for the results. Authority and fiscal responsibility should never be casually separated.

This matters in Toronto, where policing must respond to gang violence, auto theft, hate crimes, demonstrations, mental health crises, and deeply rooted concerns about racial profiling. Black, Caribbean, Indigenous, immigrant and other racialized communities are not asking for weaker policing. They want effective protection from violence and intimidation, but they also have every reason to demand transparency when enforcement priorities are established. It is particularly difficult to defend a law that names diverse communities as necessary participants in ordinary police planning, then allows their consultation rights to disappear when the minister intervenes.

The math is simple. Bill 119 contains 16 schedules, but this one provision could transfer meaningful influence over every affected local strategic plan to one provincial minister. The current minister may exercise that power responsibly, but democratic safeguards are not written for the politician we trust. They are written for the politician we do not trust.

If Ontario believes this authority is necessary, it should add firm limits. Every directive should be published with written reasons, tied to clear statutory criteria, presented to the legislature and subject to an expiry date. Affected boards and communities should be consulted, except in a narrowly defined emergency, and boards should publicly report how the directive changed priorities, staffing, and spending.

Strong policing requires clear authority, but legitimate authority requires robust accountability. Public safety should never depend on quiet directives, suspended consultation, and trust in one officeholder. If a policing priority is strong enough to override a local board, the government should be strong enough to defend it openly before the public.

Trending

Exit mobile version