World News

Is Canada paying for independence?

“What price are Canadians willing to pay to remain Canadian?”

Photographer: Will Goodman

Commenting on the collapse of Canadian-U.S. trade talks, President Donald Trump claimed Canadians “Want all the benefits of being a member of the US Union without being a member. Can’t allow that.”

Is the President right?

From the past to the present, Canada has often been riding the stagecoach of American power without fully paying for the ride. Think about it. Then consider whether you, as a taxpayer, are willing to pony up thousands more to shore up the services needed to maintain our independence from our southern neighbour.

Canada has a huge landmass, yet for years has spent proportionately less on defence than the United States. Canada only recently reached NATO’s 2% defence-spending benchmark, and the country is now committed to a 5% defence and security investment target by 2035. That means greater costs ahead. Canadians have long relied on North American defence arrangements, and the protection provided through cooperation with the United States. Canada also depends heavily on foreign suppliers for major military equipment.

Canada’s economy rests upon its well-established tradition of selling products to America. Our railways, shipping systems and aviation networks are deeply connected to the continental economy. Canadian tourism has also been heavily centred on travel to the United States. Canada’s economy is built in large part on harvesting natural resources and exporting them, including energy, minerals, forestry and agricultural products.

According to Statistics Canada, $2.5 trillion worth of Canadian corporate assets were under foreign control in 2022. That represented 14.7% of all corporate assets. U.S.-controlled enterprises accounted for 52.3% of foreign-controlled assets. The figures do not prove that Canada has lost control of its economy, but they do show how deeply foreign ownership is woven into it.

Canada has also fallen short in processing some of its resources domestically. As a result, we often rely on established international markets, including the United States, to process, distribute and purchase Canadian products.

Internationally, Canadians are often viewed as a charitable and empathetic people, willing to share with nations in need, but when the chips are down and threats emerge along critical global energy pathways, are we there to battle these bullies? Too often, America carries a larger share of the burden.

Canada is respected as a nation of peacekeepers, yet our military history also includes Canadians who have died in conflicts abroad. We are not America, yet Canada sometimes appears to be a want-to-be version of its southern neighbour.

Our media landscape is also heavily influenced by large corporations, while Canadians consume enormous amounts of American television, film and digital content. Our pride was hurt by unexpected tariffs, but economic reality keeps pulling us back toward the American market.

There is another side to the argument. Canada does not receive protection or opportunity from the United States; the relationship benefits Americans as well. Canada supplies energy, critical minerals, food and resources that support American industries. Jobs and businesses on both sides of the border are tied to this relationship. Interdependence is not the same as dependence, and that distinction matters.

The real issue may not be whether Canada receives benefits from America. The question is whether Canada has capacity to make independent choices when interests diverge.

Canada can get out of this prohibitive groove by taking greater control of its future and reducing its reliance on America, but that will cost a pretty penny. True independence requires investment in defence, infrastructure, domestic processing, transportation, technology and diversified trade.

Canadians may want more independence, prestige and freedom, but independence is a bill that eventually comes due.

So, ask yourselves the following question: If America offered a large sum of money to every Canadian aged 18 and over, and the only thing they needed to do was vote for annexation to America, would they? Perhaps the more important question is this: What price are Canadians willing to pay to remain Canadian?

Trending

Exit mobile version